Sriram Krishnan Substack

Share this post

Trust scorecard

sriramk.substack.com

Trust scorecard

Sriram Krishnan
Jan 15
14
2
Share this post

Trust scorecard

sriramk.substack.com

We increasingly don't trust the apps we use - or the ppl/governments that directly or covertly influence them.Decentralization - especially in social media - is rising in popularity. But not all "decentralization" is the same.

Here are some Qs to ask:

1/ Account mgmt:

a) How do you create and delete an account?
b) where are accounts "stored"?
c) Who has power to delete or act on accounts?

2/ Namespace architecture:

a/ Is it one global namespace or different "sub-spaces" (regions, subreddits, groups, etc)?
b/ how do usernames work across the above? Do you get to take your username across each space?
c) How do renames work?

3/ Moderation Transparency:

a) what transparency do you have on content moderation actions (account suspensions, any algorithmic levers)?
b) what is the recourse process if any?

4/ Algorithmic choice:

What options do you have on influencing the various algorithms used (picking algorithms / building your own)?

5/ Client choice:

What options do you have to use different clients/build your own?

6/ Node architecture:

If split across multiple nodes, Node trust+incentives: what is the incentive schemes for various nodes/relays/intermediaries?
What are the trust assumptions?
How do you resist centralization?

7/ Privacy and data guarantees:

What privacy and data guarantees exist at various levels of the system?

8/ Censorship resistance:

Which actors can censor content and how? (group owners, nodes,...)

9/ Centralization:

Which parts of the service need an opaque centralized service in the middle?

These are not exhaustive - and not even mutually exclusive - but think key to this evolving space as many engineers try and build here.

2
Share this post

Trust scorecard

sriramk.substack.com
2 Comments
Vidya
Jan 16

Great primer Sriram! A follow up on something you alluded to on Twitter - risk/karma scores for bad actors. You mentioned using off platform data to set scores and ban actors would be a problematic pattern, but this seems to be the best way to scale high severity offenders (terrorism, CSAM) etc. Would sharing data to remove offenders be possible in decentralized n/ws? Would love your perspective on it

Expand full comment
Reply
Patrick Killelea
Writes Patrick.net Memes
Jan 17

Thanks, tried to answer these for my own site:

https://patrick.net/post/1378305/2023-01-17-patrick-net-trust-scorecard

Expand full comment
Reply
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Sriram Krishnan
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing